Best Craftsman Mechanic Tool Sets: Buying Guide

Most likely you’re reading this because you’re in the market for a comprehensive tool set for wide range of household and car maintenance tasks. No doubt you’ll come across a number of tool sets in your local hardware store, but being faced with so many choices can easily cause confusion. So from the choices available, which brand should you go forWell… Why not Craftsman?

Best Craftsman Mechanic Tool Sets

For the last 90 years, Craftsman has become a household name due to their quality hand tools and lawn-care products. But even choosing Craftsman can leave us scratching our heads since they make several models containing specific pieces. Depending on what you’re expecting from your tool set, fulfilling your handyman-needs might only require 108-pieces, while the masters of the game could benefit from 450-piece toolkits.

Whichever one you need, Craftsman has the perfect tool set for you. We’ve taken the guesswork out for you so can focus on the facts of the top four tool boxes by Craftsman listed below.

Craftsman 450-Piece Mechanic’s Tool Set Review

This 450-piece tool set by Craftsman is definitely for the more serious home and car repair workers out there. With a comprehensive list of tools including 175 screwdrivers and 191 sockets, you most likely will not need to make repeated trips to your hardware store and search through a mountain of tools to find one that’s missing from this set. All of the pieces are made using alloy steel with a silver finish.

Craftsman 450-Piece Mechanic's Tool Set Review

This Craftsman tool set can make light of even the most complicated home or car and motorcycle maintenance jobs. If you plan on spending the whole day under the hood and tending to your car troubles, you can thank your lucky stars that this 450-piece toolbox is by your side with every tool you’d possibly need.

Craftsman 450-Piece Mechanic's Tool Set Review

However, despite being one of the most complete toolbox sets out there, several customers have found issues with it. First, one or more of the lockable drawer case side doors were either missing or sloppily fastened. Others have complaint about receiving multiples of the same-sized pieces and missing others. With a list of 450 unique pieces and sizes, there’s bound to be a box or two containing multiples of the same pieces. Craftsman has readily sent replacements and apologies for their mistakes, but it’s still a hassle having to make an official complaint for such a small but vital error.

Craftsman 165 pc Mechanics Tool Set # 38165 Review

This Craftsman mechanic tool set doesn’t contain that many tools as the previous toolset, but it is still worth considering. It is a necessary toolbox for completing everyday tasks. It can actually be an ideal set for those who are looking for an emergency kit that doesn’t take much space.

Craftsman 165 pc Mechanics Tool Set # 38165

All of the tools in this 165-piece toolset are constructed using alloy steel and plethora and given a silver-chrome finish. Not only are they durable, but they look lovely when arranged neatly in the box. These 165 tools by Craftsman should last you for several if not many many years if they’re well-cared for.

The carry case has built-in compartments for holding onto most of the pieces. The inner layout of these compartments help to keep you well organized for extra convenience. When tackling house or car maintenance jobs, you certainly don’t want to have to waste your time sorting through a cluttered toolbox just to find that one piece, and the carry case definitely keeps the pieces in order.

Craftsman 165 pc Mechanics Tool Set # 38165

One of the best things about this mechanic’s tool set by Craftsman is that it comes with all the pieces (and more) necessary for home and emergency car maintenance. With this set, you’re not paying extra for unneeded screwdriver heads or allen wrenches. However, some customers have complained about the carry case’s bad design which allows the pieces to fall out of place with just the slightest movement or bump.

Craftsman 230-Piece Mechanics Tool Set, 50230 Review

Like the previous sets, the tools in this 230-piece tool set are made using alloy steel with a silver-chrome finish. You’ll get strong, reliable tools that should last for several years with careful use and proper storage.

Craftsman 230-Piece Mechanics Tool Set, 50230

With 230 pieces stuffed into a toolbox at your disposal, you’ll definitely be able to assemble Ikea furniture and complete home DIY tasks with ease. The high piece count in this Craftsman toolbox guarantees that you’ll have every piece required for completing most, if not all, car and motorcycle repairs. Most of the tools have their own personal compartments to maintain convenience for quick work. Despite the tools’ durability and high quality construction, they are all covered under the manufacturer warranty for life; except for the screwdriver bits which can become damaged after long periods of use.

Craftsman 230-Piece Mechanics Tool Set, 50230

Although this mechanic’s tool is a perfect solution for tackling everyday home and car repairs, customers have found certain issues with the carry case and some of the tools. The case doesn’t securely fasten the tools so even the slightest bump can disarrange the box’s interior design. Next, the wrenches are much too small for several customers, and their small size keeps them loose in their compartments. Finally, the screwdriver’s magnet doesn’t hold the bits securely so simple screwing jobs requires your utmost patience.

Craftsman 108 Pc. Mechanic’s Tool Set – 009-38108 Review

The final Craftsman mechanic’s tool set on this list is the one with the least number of tools. The 108-piece set requires everything you’ll need for minor car and home repairs. You won’t be getting as many tools as the other sets on this list, but that shouldn’t be a problem if you only plan on completing small maintenance jobs and leaving the heavy work for trained professionals. Once again, the tools are made with alloy steel and given a silver-chrome finish for appeal.

Craftsman 108 Pc. Mechanic's Tool Set - 009-38108

This toolbox was designed for hobbyists or student repairmen who aren’t willing or don’t need to shell out hundreds of dollars for mysterious tools they don’t need. A toolbox at this weight and size can be a perfect choice for leaving in your truck for emergency purposes.

The carry case is uniquely designed to hold all of the sockets along the inside border, arranged in size from smallest to largest. This is especially useful for conveniently checking whether any tools are missing before packing up and storing the toolbox. The other tools have specific compartments for extra tidiness.

Craftsman 108 Pc. Mechanic's Tool Set - 009-38108

There aren’t many complaints about the carry case’s design (phew), but customers have still found things that Craftsman should pay closer attention to. The silver finish, though shiny, is weak and peels off after limited use, making the tools more prone to rusting if they aren’t taken care of. Also, the 1/4-inch driver tool spins in one direction only so might cause a slight problem for left-handed handymen.

Best Craftsman Mechanic Tool Sets: Conclusion

These are the four most widely sought-after toolbox sets by Craftsman. As you can see, Craftsman has a toolbox for every avid DIY-er our there – from the beginners who don’t know what a rancher is to the grease monkeys who can dismantle and reassemble your car and probably your home with a 108-piece set.

Best Craftsman Mechanic Tool Sets

Craftsman is dedicated to creating quality hand tools and even offers lifetime warranties for certain pieces in each of these four sets, but most likely you’ll end up misplacing them before they become worn out. If you’re looking for a mix of quality and value with a reasonable price tag, any one of these Craftsman mechanic’s tool sets is for you.

This website is supported by readers. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.